Developing Strategies for Consumer Protection Regarding Food Labeling Authorized via Electronic Submission (E-Submission)

Main Article Content

Apichart Laithong
Hathaikan Chowwanapoonpohn

Abstract

Objectives: 1) To develop strategies for consumer protection concerning food labeling authorized through the E-Submission system, 2) to assess the legality of food labels for products manufactured in Surin Province that had been approved via the E-Submission system, and 3) to evaluate the knowledge and opinions of food manufacturers regarding food labeling. Methods: This mixed-method study was divided into two phases.  Phase 1 involved legality assessment of 360 food product labels, and the evaluation of knowledge and opinions of 250 food manufacturers regarding food labeling. The findings from this phase were the input for Phase 2 in developing strategies for consumer protection concerning food labeling. Two focus group discussions were conducted among food producers and regulatory officers to identify challenges in displaying labels as required by law, and develop relevant consumer protection strategies. Results: Labelling of 216 food products (60.0%) did not comply with the law. Ready-to-eat foods had a significantly higher proportion of illegality than any other food categories (P<0.001). Average knowledge score of food producers was 8.68 ± 2.49 out of 14 (range = 2-14). Most producers held positive views on labeling. The results from focus group discussion revealed challenges in displaying labels as required by law such as a lack of knowledge and no pre-use label verification. Strategies for consumer protection regarding food labeling include three key areas. Firstly, provision of education includes organizing training sessions based on by food product categories, providing standardized label templates for convenience, and disseminating information online. Secondly, encouragement strategy includes establishing accessible consultation channels regarding labelling, requiring food producers to submit their labels for review during the authorization process, and self-examination of labels by food manufacturers. Thirdly, enforcement should be strengthened by increasing label surveillance in annual inspection plans by regulatory agencies. Warnings and orders for label correction should be applied in case of legal violation, followed by legal enforcement in case of repeated violations. Conclusion: Effective consumer protection in food labeling requires addressing the problems on illegal labeling based on food categories and implementing a participatory approach that integrates education, encouragement, and legal enforcement.

Article Details

Section
Research Articles

References

Food Act B.E. 2522. Royal Gazette No. 96, Part 79 Special (May 13, 1979).

Food Division, Food and Drug Administration. Food product licensing manual. Bangkok: Minnie Group; 2023.

Food and Drug Administration, Ministry of Public Health. Notification on the activation of food E-Submission licensing (Form SB.7). No. SorThor 1010.2/W7073 (June 20, 2016).

Head of the National Council for Peace and Order. Order No. 77/2559 on enhancing the efficiency of the health product licensing process, 2016.

Food and Drug Administration. Public manual: Licensing and modification of other food products beyond specifically controlled food, dietary supplements, royal jelly and royal jelly products, food for special purposes, cow’s milk, modified milk, fermented milk, dairy products, ice cream, beverages in sealed containers, canned foods, blended coffee, instant blended coffee, ready-to-drink coffee, and electrolyte beverages. Auto e-Submission licensing process [online]. 2024 [cited Dec 16} 2024]. Available from: food.fda.moph.go.th/ media.php?id=626032606655422464&name=Product-9.4.pdf.

Public Health Ministerial Declaration No. 450 in 2024 on regarding labeling of packaged food. Royal Gazette No. 141, Part 195D Special (July 18, 2024).

Public Health Ministerial Declaration No. 445 in 2023 on regarding nutrition labeling. Royal Gazette No. 141, Part 3D Special (November 17, 2023).

Public Health Ministerial Declaration No. 394 in 2018 on regarding foods requiring nutrition labeling and energy, sugar, fat, and sodium values in GDA format. Royal Gazette No. 135, Part 264D Special (October 22, 2018).

Food and Drug Administration. Statistical report on complaint management by the Food and Drug Administration, fiscal years 2020-2024 [online]. 2024 [cited Mar 22, 2025]. Available from: cemc.fda.moph. go.th/statistic/category/yearly-complaint-statistic.

Food and Drug Administration. Summary of consumer protection performance on health products in regional areas, fiscal year 2016. Nonthaburi: Food and Drug Administration; 2016.

Food and Drug Administration. Summary of consumer protection performance on health products in regional areas, fiscal year 2017. Nonthaburi: Food and Drug Administration; 2017.

Food and Drug Administration. Summary of consumer protection performance on health products in regional areas, fiscal year 2018. Nonthaburi: Food and Drug Administration; 2018.

Food and Drug Administration. Summary of consumer protection performance on health products in regional areas, fiscal year 2019. Nonthaburi: Food and Drug Administration; 2019.

Songsil S. Prevalence of food products with illegal claims on labels in flea markets, Loei Province. Thai Journal of Pharmacy Practice 2019; 11: 151-9.

Siripattanakulkajorn W. Creation of social measures to consumer protection on food label management, a caes study in Talaad-Thai. Thai Food and Drug Journal 2019; 26: 11–22.

Bhirommuang N, Chongsuwat R, Malai D. Perception of symbols and use of information on food labels for food choice behavior among clients of the out-patient department of Ramathibodi Hospita. J of Public Health 2012; 42: 17-28.

Parinyasiri T, Rimpeekool W. Development of the friendly format of GDA labelling for consumer. Journal of Nutrition Association of Thailand. 2017; 52: 23-33.

Yodsatern P, Glangkarn S, Wannaprapan B. Developmentof food standard surveillance process in store. Academic Journal of Community Public Health 2020; 6: 27–38.

Lertpanich P. Guidelines for developing food labeling in compliance with regulations [online]. 2023 [cited Feb6,2025]. Available from: plan.fda.moph.go. th/media.php?id=551923005899546624&name=binder19064.pdf.

Faksri P. Consumer protection manual for health products and services in the district health service network of Pho Prathap Chang, Phichit Province. Phichit: Phichit Provincial Public Health Office; 2024.

Cochran WG. Sampling techniques. 3rd ed. New York: John Wiley & Sons; 1977.

Bedrock Analytics. Deep dive into the intelligent document processing (IDP) system: AI technology for reviewing and managing documents in the digital age [online]. 2025 [cited March 23, 2025]. Available from: bedrockanalytics.ai/blog/technology/deep-dive-into-the-intelligent-document-processing-idp-system-ai-technology-for-reviewing-and-managing-documents-in-the-digital-age.