Nawamin Maharachini Health Center and Tambon Health Promoting Hospital with and without Transferred to the Lamphun Province Administrative Organization in Fiscal Year 2023

Authors

  • Tanapa Pawanla Wiang Nong Long Hospital, Lamphun Province
  • Noppcha Singweeratham Faculty of Public Health, Chiang Mai University
  • Sineenart Chautrakarn Faculty of Public Health, Chiang Mai University

Keywords:

Health Services Provision Cost, Subdistrict Health Promoting Hospital, Provincial Administrative Organization, Primary Care Management

Abstract

This retrospective study aimed to compare the total cost and cost per unit of health service provision between Nawamintharachini Health Stations and Tambon Health Promoting Hospitals (THPHs) in Lamphun Province, with and without transfer to the Provincial administrative organization. The analysis focuses on accounting costs from the perspective of the service providers for the fiscal year 2023.The purposive sampling method was used to select 12 locations, comprising 6 Nawamintharachini Health Stations and THPHs that were transferred, and 6 that were not. All cost data were collected, including labor costs, material costs, and equipment costs, using data recording forms, along with data from actual operations. The data were presented as cost amounts and percentages. The research results were as follows.

1. The total cost for the group of transferred THPHs was 27,717,405.88 baht, with 58.58% being direct costs and 41.42% being indirect costs. For the group of non-transferred THPHs, the total cost was 22,742,020.87 baht, with 61.46% being direct costs and 38.54% being indirect costs. The proportion of labor costs, material costs, and equipment costs for the transferred THPHs was 77.66%, 15.66%, and 6.68%, respectively. For the non-transferred THPHs, the proportions were 78.04%, 15.99%, and 5.97%, respectively, with labor costs being the highest in both groups.

2. The unit costs for medical activities performed by doctors and non-doctors between the transferred and non-transferred THPHs did not differ significantly. The median unit costs for the transferred THPHs were 117.19 and 115.22 baht, respectively; while for the non-transferred THPHs, the median unit costs were 109.49 and 86.46 baht, respectively. This trend was similar for other health promotion activities, except for the promotion of maternal health, where the median unit cost was higher for the transferred THPHs compared to the non-transferred ones.

Knowing the costs of providing health services is beneficial for resource management and can be used as basic information for making informed decisions regarding appropriate budget allocation to service units.

References

Chiangchaisakulthai, K., Wongsin, U., & Samiphuk, N. (2019). Unit cost of services in primary care cluster. Journal of Health Systems Research, 13(2), 175-187. (in Thai)

Dechasathian, S. (2021) The unit cost analysis of Tambon health promoting hospital under supervision of Khon Kaen provincial health office. Journal of Khon Kaen Provincial Health Office, 3(2021), 164-176. (in Thai)

Health Insurance Group. (2013). A Handbook on Unit Cost Analysis of Health Care Service. Bangkok: The Office of Permanent Secretary, Ministry of Public Health. (in Thai)

Office of Primary Health System Support. (2020). Guideline on Development of Tidao Tumbon Health Promotion Hospitals (Tiddao Tumbon Health Promotion Hospitals) 2021. Bangkok: Ministry of Public Health. (in Thai)

Office of Public Accounting Standards. (2014). A Guide for Unit Cost Calculation of Public Services for Fiscal Year 2557 B.E. Bangkok: The Comptroller General's Department. (in Thai)

Office of the Decentralization to the Local Governament Organization Committee. (2010). Guideline on The Mission Transfer of ChaloemPhrakiat 60 Phansa Nawaminrachini Health Center and Tumbon Health Promotion Hospitals to Provincial administrative Organizations. Bangkok: Office of the Permanent Secertaty the Prime Minister’s office. (in Thai)

Office of the Decentralization to the Local Governament Organization Committee. (2010). Guideline on The Mssion Transfer of Public Health Missions for Local Administrative Organizations. Bangkok: Office of the Permanent Secertaty the Prime Minister’s office. (in Thai)

Phodha, T., Singweratham, N., Rochanathimoke, O., Techakehakit, W., & Bunpean, A. (2023). A compared cost analysis for halth care services in Tambon health promotion hospitals before and during the covid 19 pandemic period fiscal year 2019 2021. The Southern College Network Journal of Nursing and Public Health, 10(1), 170-181. (in Thai)

Riewpaiboon, A. (2018). Cost Analysis in Health Systems. Bangkok: Saksopa. (in Thai)

Singweratham, N., Phodha, T., Techakehakij, W., Bunpean, A., Siewchaisakul, P., Nawsuwan, K., Sansrisawad, A., & Praesi, S. (2023) A comparison of the unit costs of health care services provided with and without transfer to local administrative organization of the Tambon health promoting hospitals. Princess of Naradhiwas University Journal, 15(3), 251-264. (in Thai)

Singweratham, N., Phodha, T., Techakehakij, W., Wongyai, D., Bunpean, A., & Siewchaisakul, P. (2022). A comparison on budget allocation of the National Health Security Fund between Contracting Unit for Primary care and the Tambon Health Promoting Hospitals with and without transferred to the Local Administrative Organizations for Policy recommendations. Bangkok: Health Systems Research Institute. (in Thai)

Sudhipongpracha, T., Ramesh, M., Chotsetakij, W., Phuripongthanawat, P., Kittayasophon, U., Satthatham, N., & Onphothong, Y. (2021). Policy analysis and policy design for the transfer of Subdistrict Health Promotion Hospitals to Provincial administrative Organizations (PAOs). Bangkok: College of interdisciplinary studies, Thammasat University. (in Thai)

Techakehakij, W., Singweratham, N., Wongyai, D. & Nawsuwan, K. (2020). Unit Cost of Primary Care Units: A Case Study in Kamphaeng Phet, Fiscal Year 2018. Journal of Safety and Health, 13(2), 192-204. (in Thai)

Wongsin, U., Wannasri, A., Thamwanna, P., Pongpattrachai, D., Chiangchaisakulthai, K., & Sakunphanit, T. (2016). Estimate unit cost per capital of services provided at cup network level. Journal of Health Systems Research, 10(3), 308-320. (in Thai)

Downloads

Published

2024-08-27