A Survey of Experimental Research on Cognitive Training Program in Older Adults with Mild Cognitive Impairment and Older Adults with Dementia

Main Article Content

Wanalak Panngam
Phachongchit Kraithaworn
Supichaya Wangpitipanit

Abstract

            The study aimed at analyzing and synthesizing experimental research on cognitive training in older adults with mild cognitive impairment and older adults with dementia in Thailand. Experimental and quasi-experimental studies published locally and internationally that met inclusion criteria were selected. Selected experimental studies that was designed with a control group and randomized for experimental and quasi-experimental studies which studied the method of cognitive training in older adults with mild cognitive impairment and older adults with dementia. Search the research report from November 2009 to September 2018. Researcher and co researchers independently assessed the quality of research using tools developed from the Joan Briggs Institute and extracting research data using the detailed research report adapted from Supaporn Playrahan. In which, the selected research met the specified criteria.
            Results revealed that 17 studies met the inclusion criteria, including 2 studies in level A (Experimental research) and 15 studies in level B (Quasi-experimental research). The cognitive training programs consisted of 3 types: 1) cognitive stimulation, 2) reminiscence, and 3) integrated type (cognitive stimulation and reminiscence). For duration and frequency of these three groups, it was found out that most of the trainings were implemented for 6 times, lasting 45 - 60 minutes/time. From 17 studies most of the programs could improve memory, increase cognitive ability and promote social interaction. There is one research that used the form of cognitive stimulation which did not show change of memory between the experimental group and the control group. The activity forms that were given to both groups were similar. However, it was found that the duration of the activities was different, with MCI group taking longer to train each time. This is probably due to older adults with MCI and older adults with dementia, had different symptoms. In older adults with MCI group had the ability to perform many tasks by themselves. While older adults with dementia had memory problems with recent events and the ability to do various activities became slower.
            Results of the study can be used the cognitive training styles to develop guidelines in older adults with mild cognitive impairment and those with dementia by applying the results to suit with their contexts. Also the results can be used as evidence for improvement of nursing care quality. In addition, health team and researchers can also conduct research as a further study.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Article Details

Section
Research Article
Author Biographies

Wanalak Panngam, Faculty of Medicine, Ramathibodi Hospital, Mahidol University

Student in Master of Nursing Science Program (Community Health Nurse Practitioner), Faculty of Medicine,

Ramathibodi Hospital, Mahidol University, Bangkok

Phachongchit Kraithaworn, Faculty of Medicine, Ramathibodi Hospital, Mahidol University

Ramathibodi School of Nursing, Faculty of Medicine, Ramathibodi Hospital, Mahidol

University,Bangkok

Supichaya Wangpitipanit, Faculty of Medicine, Ramathibodi Hospital, Mahidol University

Ramathibodi School of Nursing, Faculty of Medicine, Ramathibodi Hospital, Mahidol

University, Bangkok

References

1. Muangpaisan W. Dementia in elderly and prevention. In: Assantachai P, editor. Common health problems in elderly and prevention. Bangkok: Union creation; 2015. p. 1-2. (in Thai).

2. Alzheimer’ Disease International. Dementia in the Asia Pacific Region. [Internet]. [cited 2018 September 1]. Available from: http://www.Dementia-Asia-Pacific-2014.

3. Prasat Neurological Institute. Clinical practice guideline for dementia. Bangkok: Thana Place; 2015. (in Thai).

4. Srinonprasert V. Drug treatment for cognitive problems in dementia. In: Muangpaisan W, editor. Prevention assessment and care for dementia. Bangkok: Pappim; 2016. p. 91-5. (in Thai).

5. Institute of Geriatric Medicine and Ministry of Public Health. Manual of cognitive stimulation in people with mild cognitive impairment. Bangkok: Cyber print group; 2016. (in Thai).

6. Karuncharernpanit S. Epidemiology and knowledge of dementia. In: Senadisai S, editor. Academic article continuing education nursing science volume 17 nursing care for dementia. Bangkok: Siriyod; 2017. p. 7-8. (in Thai).

7. Muangpaisan W. Risk factors of dementia and prevention. [Internet]. [cited 2019 April 30]. Available from: http://www.si.mahidol.ac.th/sidoctor/e-pl/articledetail.asp?id=415. (in Thai).

8. Hongtong R, Sasat S. The effect of reminiscence program on cognitive function of older people with dementia. JONAE 2015;8(1):99-112. (in Thai).

9. Carrion C, Folkvord F, Anastasiadou D, Aymerich M. Cognitive therapy for dementia patients: a systematic review. Dement Geriatr Cogn Disord 2018;46(1-2):1-26.

10. Pratoomtan D, Munkhetvit P, Rattakorn P. Effect of home-based cognitive training kit and satisfaction of elderly with mild cognitive impairment. [Internet]. [cited 2018 April 10]. Available from: http://www.ams.cmu.ac.th/lib/index.php?go=2&to=4&id=678&lang=en.

11. Duangkaew J, Sasat S. The effect of cognitive training program on cognitive function in mild cognitive impairment older people in governmental welfare home for the aged. JOPN 2018;10(1):12-20. (in Thai).

12. Chaiwong P, Rattakorn P, Mumkhetvit P. Effects of cognitive training program on cognitive abilities and quality of life in elderly with suspected dementia. Bull Chiang Mai Assoc Med Sci 2015;48(3):182-91. (in Thai).

13. Sornjiengkhum R, Sucamvang K. Effectiveness of memory training program implementation among elderly with early-stage dementia, memory clinic, Lampang Hospital. [Internet]. [cited 2018 April 12]. Available from: http://www.cmuir.cmu.ac.th/jspui/handle/6653943832/45836. (in Thai).

14. Kriengkaisakda W, Chadcham S. Development of a brain-training rehabilitation program based on neurobics exercise theory for patients with mild dementia. RMCS 2012;10(1):11-25. (in Thai).

15. Aebthaisong O, Sangon S, Intarasombat P. A synthesis of research on memory training in older adults with dementia. [Master’s Thesis, Faculty of Nursing]. Mahidol University; 2010. (in Thai).

16. Craig JV, Smyth RL. The evidence-based practice manual for nurse. London: Churchill Livingstone; 2002.

17. Joanna Briggs Institute. Critical appraisal tool. [Internet]. [cited 2018 December 10]. Available from http://joannabriggs.org/research/critical-appraisal-tools.html.

18. Pahiraphan S, Maneesriwongkoon W, Panpakdee O. A survey of experimental and quasi-experimental nursing research about diabetic patients in Thailand. [Master’s Thesis, Faculty of Nursing]. Mahidol University; 2008. (in Thai).

19. Sritonchai J, Sucamvang K. Effectiveness of memory training program implementation among elderly with mild cognitive impairment Pua District, Nan Province. [Master’s Thesis, Faculty of Nursing]. Chiang Mai University; 2015. (in Thai).

20. Chaiwong P, Mumkhetvit P, Rattakorn P. Effects of cognitive training program on cognitive abilities and quality of life in elderly with suspected dementia. Bull Chiang Mai Assoc Med Sci 2015;48(3):182-91. (in Thai).

21. Suwanmosi P, Kaspichayawattana J. The effects of cognitive stimulation program on memory of community-dwelling older persons with mild cognitive impairment. JOPN 2016;8(2):45-57. (in Thai).

22. Samael L, Thaniwattananon P, Kongin W. The effect of muslim-specific montessori-based brain-raining program on promoting cognition in muslim elderly at risk of dementia. Princess of Naradhiwas University Journal 2016;8(2):16-27. (in Thai).

23. Kansri J, Jongpanich D, Teianukool N, Srinuan P, Soonthornchaiya R. The effect of brain exercise on memory enhancement among the elderly with mild cognitive impairment.

24. Nursing Journal of the Ministry of Public Health 2017;27(3):176-87. (in Thai).
Nakawiro D, Chansirikarn S, Srisuwan P, Aebthaisong O, Sudsakorn P, Vidhyachak C, et al. Group-based training of executive function, attention, memory and visuospatial function (Team-V) in patients with mild neurocognitive disorder. J Psychiatric Assoc Thailand 2017;62(4):337-48. (in Thai).

25. Ramking N, Soonthornchaiya R, Vuthiarpa S. The effect of a cognitive stimulation program on the cognitive function of older adults with mild cognitive impairment. Journal of Nursing and Health Care 2018;36(2):114-22. (in Thai).

26. Limsakul W, Tanseng K, Puekkong J. The effectiveness of a cognitive stimulation program on the elderly with mild cognitive impairment. Nursing Journal 2018;45(3):58-68. (in Thai).

27. Limsakul W, Aiemkhum B, Kongsanae P. Cognitive stimulation with mild cognitive impairment in people. Reg 11 Med J 2018;32(3):1143-54. (in Thai).

28. Sukontapola C, Kemsenb S, Chansirikarnc S, Nakawirod D, Kuhae O, Taemeeyapraditb U. The effectiveness of a cognitive training program in people with mild cognitive impairment: a study in urban community. Asian J Psychiatry 2018;35(2):18-23. (in Thai).

29. Kriengkaisakda W, Chadcham S. Development of a brain-training rehabilitation program based on neurobics exercise theory for patients with mild dementia. Research Methodology & Cognitive Science 2012;10(1):11-25. (in Thai).

30. Trikun S, Kangjai W, Somanusorn S. Development of clinical nursing practice guideline for memory training among elderly with dementia at Tavatburi hospital, Roi-ed province. [Master’s Thesis, Faculty of Nursing]. Burapha University; 2008. (in Thai).

31. Trakulsithichoke S, Suwan A. Effects of a cognitive stimulation program on the cognitive abilities and ability to perform the activities of daily living in elders who are at risk of or have dementia. Thai Red Cross Nursing Journal 2016;9(2):145-58. (in Thai).

32. Glass GV, McGaw B, Smith ML. Meta-analysis in social research. Beverly Hills (CA): SAGE Publications; 1981.

33. Hsu JL, Fan YC, Huang YL, Wang J, Chen WH, Chiu HC, Bai CH. Improved predictive ability of the Montreal Cognitive Assessment for diagnosing dementia in a community-based study. Alzheimers Res Ther 2015;7(1):69.

34. Royal College of Physicians of Thailand. Research quality. Bangkok: Department of Nursing Faculty of Medicine Ramathibodi Hospital, Mahidol University; 2014. (in Thai).