Lumpy Demand Forecasting for Slow-moving Medicines: A Case Study of Community Hospital Thailand

Main Article Content

Phattaraporn Kalaya
Preecha Termsuksawad
Thananya Wasusri

Abstract

Introduction: The small community hospitals, a case study in Thailand always face inventory management problems such as shortages and overstocks of medicines because of unpredictable demand, particularly irregular demand. The irregular demand which zero demand were appeared many periods and demand values can vary greatly. It was known as lumpy demand. It obviously appears in case of slow moving vital medicines that they are critically needed for the patients. Objective aimed to examine the effectiveness of forecasting method for the slow-moving medicines in small community hospitals. Methods: The study compared the effectiveness of two forecasting methods; Croston’s method (CR) and the Teunter, Syntetos, and Babai’s (TSB) method. The simulation was analyzed using historical data, obtained from a community hospital in Thailand.  The data were collected from January 2015 to December 2016. Indicators used in this study are the mean square error (MSE) and shortage. Results: Result pointed out that the pattern of irregular demand and interval to adjust the smoothing constant values affect to the effectiveness of forecasting method.TSB method outperformed the Croston’s method, indicated by smaller MSEs, when applied to V1’s pattern whereas Croston’s method outperformed in case of shortage indicator. Both Croston’s and TSB method obtained smaller MSEs when the smoothing constant values were remained the same to 8 and 12 weeks. However, the numbers of shortage for both methods were high. Conclusion: When the forecasting method were applied to forecast irregular demand, demand pattern, the variation of demand and demand interval should be concerned. Because those issues affect to forecasting value that it could lead to shortage or over inventory.

Article Details

Section
Pharmaceutical Practice

References

Babai M.Z, Syntetos A ,Teunter R. Intermittent demand forecasting : An empirical study on accuracy and the risk of obsolescence. Production Economics 2014 :212-219.

Costantino F, GravioDi.G, Patriarca R , Petrella L. Spare parts management for irregular demand items.Omega 2017:1-10.

Croston J.D. Forecasting and Stock Control for Intermittent Demands. Operational Research Quarterly 23 1972: 289–303.

Kourentzes N.On intermittent demand model optimization and selection. Production Economics 2014:180-190.

Official website of The Small and Medium Enterprises Promotion.The overview of Healthcare industry in Thailand [Online].2014. [Cite 2014 Mar 17]. Available from: https://www.sme.go.th/eng/4.

Pirankar SB , Ferreira Am , Vaz FS, Pereira-Antao I ,Pinto NR ,Perni SG. Application of ABC-VED analysis in the medical stores of a tertiary care hospital. International

Journal of Pharmacology & Toxicology 2014 :175-177.

Regattieri A ,Gamberi M ,Gamberini R & Manzini R.Managing lumpy demand for aircraft spare parts.Journal of Air Transport Management 2005:426-431.

Silver E.A.Inventory management: an overview; Canadian publications, practical applications and suggestions for future research” 2008 INFOR 46:15–28.

Srinivasan A.V. Managing a Modern Hospital,2nd Edition.SAGE Publication 2008,New Delhi , India.

Syntetos A.A , Boylan J.E.The accuracy of intermittent demand estimates. International Journal of Forecasting 2005:303-314.

Syntetos A.A , Boylan J.E.On the Variance of Intermittent demand estimates. International Journal Production Economics 2010:546-555.

Spyros G , Makridakis S.G , Hibon M.Evaluating Accuracy (or Error) Measures in INSEAD working paper Volume 9518 of Working papers / INSEAD 1995.

Thai Health Coding Center.Hospital classification in Thailand. [Online].2015. [Cite 2015 Aug 14]. Available from: https://thcc.or.th/reporthcode.html.

Teunter R.H ,Syntetos A.A , Babai M,Z. Intermittent demand: Linking forecasting to inventory obsolescence. European Journal of Operation Research 2011:606-615.

WallstrÖm P & Segerstedt A.Evaluation of forecasting error measurements and techniques for intermittent demand. International Journal Production Economics 2010:625-

World Health Organization. Drug and Therapeutics Committees - A Practical Guide [Online].2003. [Cite 2015 Mar 30]. Available from: https://apps.who.int/medicinedocs/pdf/s4882e/s4882e.pdf