A systematic review of the effect of music therapy compared to speech therapy on social communication skills in preschool children with autism spectrum disorder
Article Sidebar
Main Article Content
Abstract
Background: Autism spectrum disorder (ASD) is defined by impairment in social communication and the presence of restricted interests and repetitive behaviors. Individuals with ASD receive a variety of interventions tailored to their specific needs, enhancing their social, communication, and adaptive skills. Speech therapy (ST) aims to promote speech and language development and further improve social and communication skills in children diagnosed with ASD. Music therapy (MT) has been recognized as an intervention for individuals with ASD to facilitate social and communication skills. At present, there is no systematic review (SR) of MT compared to ST on social communication skills in preschool children with ASD.
Objective: This SR aimed to (a) investigate the effectiveness of MT compared to ST on social communication skills for preschool children with ASD and (b) investigate which type of MT, compared to ST, affects the social communication skills of preschool children with ASD.
Materials and methods: This SR was conducted following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines using five databases: the CINAHL Complete, PubMed, Scopus, ERIC, and Cochrance. The researchers also conducted a hand search for reference lists of identified articles and pertinent reviews for additional studies. We assessed the risk of bias using the Risk of Bias in Non-randomized Studies-of Interventions (ROBINS-I) tool and the Revised Cochrane risk-of-bias tool for randomized trials (RoB 2).
Results: The initial literature search yielded 63 articles. Following the exclusion of non-relevant studies, 2 studies met the inclusion criteria for this review. The results indicated that the differences in overall efficacy between MT and ST were not statistically significant. Both therapies are effective for speech production, including semantics, phonology, pragmatics, and prosody in preschool children with ASD. MT, specifically developmental speech and language training through music (DSLM), is equally successful as ST in enhancing speech production. Behavioral intervention, applied behavior analysis verbal behavior (ABA-VB), is also effective in improving core symptoms of autism, such as social and communication deficits.
Conclusion: MT has comparable efficacy in enhancing speech production compared to ST, which impacts social communication in preschool children with ASD. Nevertheless, ST remains a cornerstone in addressing communication deficits in children with ASD, focusing on structured speech and language development. MT provides a complementary approach that can enhance speech production and bring more enjoyment to these young children, who frequently struggle with social communication. Therefore, MT could be viewed as a complementary approach to traditional ST. Limitations included research on the use of DSLM and ABA-VB by music therapists has been sparse, and the number of studies has been small. Further study would allow for more precise conclusions regarding the effect of MT compared to ST on social communication skills in preschool children with ASD.
Article Details
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
Personal views expressed by the contributors in their articles are not necessarily those of the Journal of Associated Medical Sciences, Faculty of Associated Medical Sciences, Chiang Mai University.
References
American Psychiatric Association. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 5th Ed.; American Psychiatric Association: Arlington, VA, USA, 2013.
Yanti YN, Jannah SS, Nadia S, Wahdaniyah I, Mutmimah M. Speech therapy to overcome language disorders in autistic children. IJECE. 2022; 3(1): 55-66. doi:10.35 719/ gns.v3i1.61
Osman HA, Haridi M, Gonzalez NA, Dayo SM, Fatima U, Sheikh A, et al. A systematic review of the efficacy of early initiation of speech therapy and its positive impact on autism spectrum disorder. Cureus. 2023; 15(3): e35930. doi:10.7759/cureus.35930
Bieleninik Ł, Geretsegger M, Mössler K, Assmus J, Thompson G, Gattino G, Elefant C, Gottfried T, Igliozzi R, Muratori F, Suvini F. Effects of improvisational music therapy vs enhanced standard care on symptom severity among children with autism spectrum disorder: The TIME-A randomized clinical trial. JAMA. 2017; 318(6): 525-35. doi: 10.1001/jama.2021.4108
Bharathi G, Venugopal A, Vellingiri B. Music therapy as a therapeutic tool in improving the social skills of autistic children. Egypt J Neurol Psychiatry Neurosurg. 2019; 55: 1-6. doi:10.1186/s41983-019-0091-x
Thompson GA, McFerran KS, Gold C. Familycentred music therapy to promote social engagement in young children with severe autism spectrum disorder: A randomized controlled study. Child Care Health Dev. 2014; 40(6): 840-52. doi:10.1111/cch.12121
Dănciulescu T, Zaharia A. Piano with a twist: A pilot study exploring the preliminary effects of a piano therapy program for children with autism spectrum disorder. Arts Psychother. 2023; 82: 101987. doi:10.10 16/j.aip.2022.101987
Tsirigoti A, Georgiadi M. The Efficacy of Music Therapy Programs on the Development of Social Communication in Children with Autism Spectrum Disorder: A Systematic Review. Educ Sci. 2024; 14(4): 373. doi:10.3390/educsci14040373
Callan DE, Tsytsarev V, Hanakawa T, Callan AM, Katsuhara M, Fukuyama H, et al. Song and speech: brain regions involved with perception and covert production. Neuroimage. 2006; 31(3): 1327-42. doi:10.1016/j.neuroimage.2006.01.036
Özdemir E, Norton A, Schlaug G. Shared and distinct neural correlates of singing and speaking. Neuroimage. 2006; 33(2): 628-35. doi:10.1016/j.neuroimage.2006. 07.013
Zhao C, Ong JH, Veic A, Patel AD, Jiang C, Fogel AR, et al. Predictive processing of music and language in autism: Evidence from Mandarin and English speakers. Autism Res. 2024; 17(6): 1230-57. doi:10.1002/aur. 3133
Luo E, Pan C, Fan X. Music, Language, and Autism: Neurological Insights for Enhanced Learning. Int J Innov Res Med Sci. 2023; 8(9): 398-408. doi: 10.23958/ ijirms/vol08-i09/1743.
Lim HA. Effect of “Developmental Speech and Language Training Through Music” on Speech Production in Children with Autism Spectrum Disorders. J Music Ther. 2010; 47(1): 2-26. doi:10.1093/jmt/47.1.2
Lim HA, Draper E. The effects of music therapy incorporated with applied behavior analysis verbal behavior approach for children with autism spectrum disorders. J Music Ther. 2011; 48(4): 532-50. doi:10. 1093/jmt/48.4.532
Page MJ, McKenzie JE, Bossuyt PM, Boutron I, Hoffmann TC, Mulrow CD, et al. The PRISMA 2020 statement: an updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews. BMJ. 2021; 372: n71. doi:10.1136/ bmj.n71
Sterne JA, Hernán MA, Reeves BC, Savovic J, Berkman ND, Viswanathan M, et al. ROBINS-I: a tool for assessing risk of bias in non-randomised studies of interventions. BMJ. 2016; 355: i4919. doi:10.1136/ bmj.i4919
Higgins JP, Altman DG, Gøtzsche PC, Jüni P, Moher D, Oxman AD, et al. The Cochrane Collaboration’s tool for assessing risk of bias in randomised trials. BMJ. 2011; 343: d5928. doi:10.1136/bmj.d5928
Newhouse RP, Dearholt SL, Poe SS, Pugh LC, White KM. Johns Hopkins nursing evidence-based practice model and guidelines. Indianapolis, in: Sigma Theta Tau International Honor Society of Nursing; 2007.
Cooley J. The use of developmental speech and language training through music to enhance quick incidental learning in children with autism spectrum disorders [Master’s thesis]. Colorado State University; 2012.
Chevallier C, Kohls G, Troiani V, Brodkin ES, Schultz RT. The social motivation theory of autism. Trends Cogn Sci. 2012; 16(4): 231-9. doi:10.1016/j.tics. 2012.02.007
Kuhl PK, CoffeyCorina S, Padden D, Dawson G. Links between social and linguistic processing of speech in preschool children with autism: behavioral and electrophysiological measures. Dev Sci. 2005; 8(1): F1-2. doi:10.1111/j.1467-7687.2004.00384.x
Demaine K. Musical echolalia and non-verbal children with autism [Doctoral dissertation]. Lesley University; 2012.
Bruscia KE. Music in the assessment and treatment of echolalia. Music Ther. 1982; 2(1): 25-41. doi:10.1093/ mt/2.1.25
Sundberg ML, Partington JW. Teaching language to children with autism and other developmental disabilities. Pleasant Hill, CA: Behavior Analysts; 1998.
Guzinski EM, Cihon TM, Eshleman J. The effects of tact training on stereotypic vocalizations in children with autism. Anal Verbal Behav. 2012; 28: 101-10. doi:10.1007/BF03393110
LaGasse AB. Developmental speech and language training through music (DSLM). In: Thaut MH, Hoemberg V, Eds. Handbook of neurologic music therapy. Oxford University Press; 2014. 197-216.
Prizant BM. Language acquisition and communicative behavior in autism: Toward an understanding of the “whole” of it. J Speech Hear Disord. 1983; 48(3): 296- 307. doi: 10.1044/jshd.4803.296
Helen, Tager-Flusberg., Rhea, Paul., Catherine, Lord. 1. Language and communication in autism. 2005. doi: 10.1002/9780470939345.CH12
Skinner NF. Learned helplessness: Performance as a function of task significance. J Psychol. 1979; 102(1): 77-82. doi:10.1080/00223980.1979.9915097
Barbera ML. The verbal behavior approach: How to teach children with autism and related disorders. Jessica Kingsley Publishers; 2007.
Carr JE, Firth AM. The verbal behavior approach to early and intensive behavioral intervention for autism: A call for additional empirical support. J Early Intensive Behav Interv. 2005; 2(1): 18. doi:10.1037/ h0100297
Binns AV, Cunningham BJ, Andres A, Oram Cardy J. Current practices, supports, and challenges in speech-language pathology service provision for autistic preschoolers. Autism Dev Lang Impair. 2022; 7: 23969415221120768. doi:10.1177/239694 15221120768